40 Amish Recipes
These old fashioned Amish recipes are hearty, comforting, and delicious.
Simple and made with the freshest ingredients, country cooking always satisfies a hungry family—and nothing says country cooking more than traditional Amish food. We've gathered a list of some of our best Amish recipes that we wanted to share with you.
You can create a variety of hearty traditional Amish recipes that will have your family proudly sitting around the dinner table. From the sweet aroma of Amish fry pies to the succulent flavors of homemade ham and noodles, there is something for everyone when it comes to home-style cooking and Amish food.
Using ingredients that are available in most American kitchens, these traditional Amish recipes don't rely on fancy cuts or expensive spices. Made with the simplicity and love, every recipe in this mouth-watering collection is perfect for the budget conscious. Our collection of wonderful recipes comes from the heartland and are a hearty fare. Simple and delicious, make these traditional Amish meals for your family tonight.
Amish Bread Recipes
Test Kitchen Approved Amish Cinnamon Bread - Enjoy all of the rich flavors of this traditional Amish bread, but you don't have to worry about cooking with yeast.
Simple Amish White Bread - This traditional bread recipe is perfect for sandwiches, snacking, and more. You'll love the unrivaled freshness of homemade bread.
Test Kitchen Approved Shortcut Amish Apple Bread - This sweet bread recipe is filled with fresh apples, for a country-style bread that can't be beat.
Test Kitchen Approved Shortcut Amish Friendship Bread - This traditional Amish recipe gets a time-saving change (no starter required!).
Amish Buttermilk Biscuits - Dinner isn't complete without a delicious biscuit or two. This Amish recipe is a great one to try.
Amish Potato Rolls - Rich, fluffy, and completely scrumptious, these Amish potato rolls are made for a little butter and homemade jam.
Amish Cornbread - This delicious cornbread recipe is the perfect side dish to any of our Amish dinner recipes below. Keep scrolling to find more amazing meal ideas!
Amish Breakfast Recipes
Test Kitchen Approved Amish Apple Bread - Everyone will love this sweet and satisfying Amish breakfast recipe.
Amish Breakfast Puffs - These delicious cinnamon-sugar muffins will make anyone's morning brighter.
Test Kitchen Approved Ultimate Amish Breakfast Casserole - A hearty breakfast is perfect for a day spent working outside. It's also great for a busy Saturday mornings.
Amish Dinner Recipes
Test Kitchen Approved Amish-Style Ground Beef Casserole - Traditional Amish food is filling and made with homestyle ingredients. This casserole is both of those things, plus it's easy to make!
5-Ingredient Amish Baked Spaghetti - If your family likes pasta, they will love this delicious baked spaghetti recipe.
Test Kitchen Approved Amish Ham Balls - You can easily feed a crowd with this irresistible Amish meal.
Pennsylvania Dutch Ham & Noodle Casserole - Hearty and comforting, this noodle casserole is the perfect family dinner.
Amish Yumasetti Casserole - This filling casserole is rich, delicious, and one of our favorite Amish meals.
Test Kitchen Approved Dump and Go Amish Casserole - Amish recipes are made to fuel a hard day's work. This dinner will fill you up and give you energy for whatever chores you need to do.
Test Kitchen Approved Amish Friendship Soup - If you're craving a homemade soup that will warm your body and soul, you're in the right place!
Amish Church Soup - This delicious soup recipe is rich, delicious, and perfect with fresh crusty bread.
Test Kitchen Approved Amish Potato Salad - Amish communities often grow their own vegetables, including potatoes. While you might not have home grown potatoes for this recipe, we think you'll still love the homestyle flavors and seasonings.
Learn more about this classic Amish side dish!Difference Between Amish & Regular Potato Salad
Test Kitchen Approved Amish Broccoli Salad - This delicious side dish is the perfect addition to any dinner or potluck.
Amish Hamburger Casserole - This comforting Amish dinner recipe is perfect for busy weeknights. It will fill you up and remind you of how amazing home cooked dinners are.
Test Kitchen Approved Easy Amish Meatloaf - This hearty dinner recipe is sure to satisfy a hungry family.
Amish Dessert Recipes
Yoder's Amish Chocolate Pie - This rich chocolate pie is the perfect end to a home-cooked meal.
Amish Country's Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies - These delicious cookies will melt in your mouth. They are rich and not too sweet.
Amish Applesauce Cake - Looking for a dessert that's not too sweet? This applesauce cake is moist and flavorful, with just the right amount of sweetness.
Test Kitchen Approved Baked Amish Apple Custard Dessert - Amish communities are famous for their baked goods. This apple dessert is a classic that you can try in your own kitchen.
Shoo Fly Pie - This traditional Amish recipe is a classic for a reason! It's perfectly sweet, gooey, and satisfying.
Test Kitchen Approved Amish Whoopie Pie - Whoopie pies are made by sandwiching two slices of chocolate cake with a sweet cream filling. This delicious version is easy to make, and completely scrumptious.
Amish Style Church Windows Dessert - If you like chocolate, then you will love this delicious chocolaty-marshmallow masterpiece.
Test Kitchen Approved Amish Peanut Butter Pie - Bursting with rich peanut flavor, this indulgent pie recipe is perfect for potlucks and simple family gatherings alike.
Classic Amish Buttermilk Pie - Everyone will want a second slice of this delicious buttermilk pie.
Traditional Amish Oatmeal Pie - This oatmeal pie has the perfect amount of sweetness. Serve with a dollop of whipped cream or vanilla ice cream!
Amish Brown Sugar Dessert Dumplings - This delicious recipe has been passed down from generation to generation. It's made with melt-in-your-mouth homemade dumplings and a sweet sugar syrup. Yum!
Test Kitchen Approved Amish Apple Fry Pies - Amish fry pies are known for being absolutely delicious. Luckily, you can make your own version at home using this recipe!
Old Fashioned Amish Lemon Sponge Pie - This traditional Amish dessert is sweet-and-tart with plenty of lemon flavor.
Authentic Amish Strawberry Shortcake - This dessert is great any time of year, but it's at its best during the summer when you can find fresh strawberries in the garden.
Old Fashioned Funeral Pie - Made with raisins and orange juice, this fruit-filled pie is the perfect potluck dish.
Test Kitchen Approved Amish Cinnamon Cream Cheese Roll-Ups - These delicious cinnamon roll ups are so easy to make! And they're perfect for a dessert or snack.