close

Search Term

Enter a search term (optional)

Categories

Select One (optional)

Image

(optional)

Show only results that have an image


Holiday

Select as many as you like (optional)

  • Christmas
  • Cinco de Mayo
  • Earth Day
  • Easter
  • Fall
  • Father's Day
  • Halloween
  • Jewish Holiday
  • Kwanzaa
  • Mother's Day
  • New Year's
  • Patriotic Holiday
  • Spring
  • St. Patrick's Day
  • Summer
  • Thanksgiving
  • Valentine's Day
  • Winter
  • Back to School
  • Birthdays
  • Fourth of July
  • Labor Day
  • Memorial Day
Cuisine Type

Select as many as you like (optional)

  • American
  • Amish
  • Asian
  • Chinese
  • French
  • Greek
  • Indian
  • Italian
  • Japanese
  • Jewish
  • Mexican
  • Southern
  • Tropical

Seasonal

Select as many as you like (optional)

  • Spring
  • Summer
  • Fall
  • Winter
Cooking Method

Select as many as you like (optional)

  • Casserole
  • Grilling
  • Microwave
  • No Bake
  • Oven
  • Pressure Cooker
  • Skillet
  • Slow Cooker
Cooking Time

Select One (optional)

Preparation Time

Select One (optional)

Chill Time

Select One (optional)

Number of Ingredients

Select One (optional)

Slow Cooker Time HIGH

Select One (optional)

Slow Cooker Time LOW

Select One (optional)

RecipeLion.com

Menu

Free Offer
22 Easy Pie Recipes for Every Occasion

No matter what time of year, you are guaranteed to find a delicious pie recipe for your friends and family to enjoy. Make any of these easy pie recipes for your occasion with this FREE eCookbook!

Bonus: Get our newsletter & special offers for free. We will not share or sell your email address. View our Privacy Policy

Latest Comments

Amish Peanut Butter Pie

By: Brandy from nutmegnanny.com

Amish Peanut Butter Pie
Amish Peanut Butter Pie
This image courtesy of nutmegnanny.com

This isn't your average cream cheese-based peanut butter pie recipe. Amish Peanut Butter Pie goes above and beyond what you typically think of peanut butter pies. This no bake pie is made with a homemade vanilla pudding and peanut butter nuggets, so the peanut butter flavor isn't overpowering and the texture is creamy and delicate. Simply assemble the pie and slather the top with homemade whipped cream. Once it's set, you'll have a mind-blowing Amish dessert that will become a family favorite during the summer.

Chilling Time: 2 hr

Cooking Vessel Size: 9 X 9-inch Pie Plate

Notes

Let the pie set in the fridge for 2 hours before serving.

Your Recently Viewed Recipes

Include a Photo Include a Photo

Click the button above or drag and drop images onto the button. You can upload two images.

Cancel Reply to Comment

Thanks for your comment. Don't forget to share!

There are a lot of recipes out there that call themselves Amish, but whenever I see instant pudding mix or cool whip in the ingredients list, I know that it is not quite that. This pie is much more authentic since you actually do make the pudding using real ingredients. The peanut butter nuggets are a great idea, and could be used for other desserts like cookies, or to top an ice cream sundae!

This looks absolutely dreamy. I'd be tempted to just use a box of instant pudding, but I would like to try making it from scratch. Her suggestion about trying it with a chocolate pudding sounds incredibly tasty and I'd love to experiment with that variation. Chocolate and peanut butter just go so well together and a pie combining both would be delicious.

I love banana cream pies and coconut cream pies, so I am sure I will love peanut butter cream pie. The whipped cream and peanut butter "nuggets" must make it wonderful! What is vanilla bean paste? I really don't make pies from scratch, so I might use the idea below and put it in a graham cracker crust.

You had me at peanut butter! I love cream pies. I have never heard of a pie like this. Most peanut butter pies I know of are cream cheese based, just like it says. There are Amish near me, but I have only seen jams and jellies and other fruit based baked goods. I can't wait to try this.

This is quite the peanut butter pie! Beautiful, creamy, fluffy, flavorful- all at the same time! The vanilla pudding is really the key ingredient. It adds a rich texture to the pie, while also matching the flavor of the peanut butter a little so it isn't too overpowering! Plus, it's a no-bake recipe which is a nice and simple aspect!

This seems so perfect, since I love peanut butter, but I'm worried it would taste a little too strongly of pb.

AMISH IS THE WAY TO GO NOW DAYS,,,IT HAS NO ADDED GARBAGE LIKE CHEMICALS WE EAT THESE DAYS,,S ITS OVER THE TOP YUMMY!!!

This was an amazing pie! My daughter said it tasted like a fluffly cloud of peanut butter heaven. I used a graham cracker crust as I didn't have time to make pie crust, and it was still soooo good!

Close

Report Inappropriate Comment

Are you sure you would like to report this comment? It will be flagged for our moderators to take action.

Thank you for taking the time to improve the content on our site.

Recipe of the Day

Strawberry Jello Pretzel Salad

Perfect for a family party or a potluck dinner, recipes with jello are always crowd-pleasers. Strawberry Jello Pretzel Salad is… See more

Get More Recipes
Something worth saving?

Register now for FREE to:

  • SAVE your favorite recipes
  • ADD personal notes
  • GET fast cooking tips

 

Connect With Us

Facebook Google Plus Instagram Twitter Pinterest
Twitter Blog Email RSS

About Us Advertise Contact Us FAQ Keyword Index Privacy Policy Submit Your Recipes Subscribe Terms of Service Unsubscribe

---- 1 ----

close

Images from other cooks

There are currently no images from other cooks.